Episode 52
Lindsay Clancy’s Hung Jury: An Attorney Breaks Down What Happens Next
September 3, 2026
Episode 52
September 3, 2026
The jury is deadlocked. Attorney Keisha Toni Derry breaks down what happens next in the Lindsay Clancy trial.
As the nation watches the Lindsay Clancy case unfold in Plymouth Superior Court, attorney Keisha Toni Derry joins Marcia Upson to break down the legal side of one of the most closely watched trials in the country. With the jury reporting they’re deadlocked after days of deliberation, Keisha walks through exactly what’s at stake: Massachusetts’ unique burden-shifting insanity defense, the five verdict options the jury is weighing, and why she believes this case may end the way Andrea Yates’ did decades ago.
This is Part 2 of a two-part series — don’t miss Part 1 with nurse Gina Overby on the psychiatric side of postpartum psychosis.